This superbly produced single was released on April 12, 1969. Opening like a Four Seasons song, it should have been a top ten hit on Billboard, but it peaked at #32. Sisters Bonnie and Pat Lamdin provide the glorious vocals.
Here’s one, from 1966, that didn’t even chart on Billboard. Sincerely, this was how it felt being young in Christian Fellowship.

I’ll ask Denro what the competition was that held this one back.
OMG! Just yesterday I was listening to “Best One Hit Wonders of 1969,” and immediately thought of that great Peppermint Rainbow song, which didn’t make the cut and I had all but forgotten!
Twinster psychic communication!